Moon Over Soho

What it’s about

A string of deaths among London jazz musicians draws Peter into Soho’s musical history while a second investigation points towards a dangerous practitioner.

Peter is no longer merely adjusting to an impossible witness. His police work now takes him into the musical life of Soho, where deaths among jazz musicians require the ordinary questions of a murder enquiry as well as attention to unusual evidence. The first-person voice keeps the neighbourhood specific: performances, working musicians and the streets around them matter more than an abstract idea of nightlife. Family connections make the music personal for Peter, while a second strand suggests that magical practice exists beyond the Folly's tidy explanations. This is still a contemporary London case, but its atmosphere is more nocturnal and its concerns intimate. The opening premise asks how a detective listens to a city when the city's music may be part of the evidence.

Why it works

This instalment is darker, more intimate and more musical than the first. Peter’s family history gives the investigation emotional weight, while Soho allows the series to explore how memory can cling to streets, clubs and performances. The two investigative threads create a busier structure, but they also broaden the continuing story.

The move from an introductory case to a second novel changes what the series can assume. Readers know why Peter asks apparently eccentric questions, so the book can spend more time on what those questions cost him when music and family enter the investigation. Soho is a working neighbourhood here as well as a shorthand for glamour. Treating a performance as labour, memory and a potential clue gives the mystery a texture that an interchangeable nightclub setting would not provide.

Peter's habit of explaining himself remains funny, but the jokes now have more to push against. A musical association can stir affection at the same moment a police enquiry demands detachment. That tension gives the two strands their purpose. One follows a local pattern of deaths; the other reminds us that London's supernatural life is not obliged to present itself as a single neat case. The novel is at its best when those concerns alter the way Peter listens rather than simply adding more incident.

This is also where the series becomes less inclined to pause for a new reader. Nightingale, the Folly and Peter's early training continue from the first book, while established relationships carry a weight that a quick recap would flatten. The busier shape can sometimes make the momentum uneven: a reader looking for one clean investigation may resent a diversion just as the music has taken hold. Yet the wider structure earns its place by showing that Peter's new work has consequences outside the immediate crime. The result sounds less like a second attempt at the debut and more like a series finding its capacity for different registers.

How the audiobook sounds

The narration benefits from the book’s musical rhythm. Holdbrook-Smith makes Peter’s family relationships feel lived-in and handles the shifts between banter, attraction and threat without overselling them. His returning character voices are already recognisable, allowing the performance to move quickly through a widening cast.

Music makes timing unusually important in this recording. The voice cannot provide a live jazz performance, and it does not need to: brief changes in pace can make a remembered performance feel different from a witness answering a direct question. Peter's family conversations also ask for a more personal register than his exchanges at work. The delivery lets those settings sound connected without flattening them into the same tone.

Returning characters are easier to recognise after the first audiobook, which helps when the case changes venue or investigative strand. Listen for how a joke lands differently in an intimate conversation and in a room where Peter is trying to keep his professional footing. On a commute, the chapters offer enough local atmosphere to make a short listen satisfying; longer sessions make the movement between musical and investigative scenes clearer. Someone expecting music to be literally reproduced in the audio may prefer to supply their own soundtrack. The performance's achievement is to give the written references rhythm without pretending to be a concert.

Compare every narrator →